I’ve just added a page explaining the West Lothian question to those on the blog. It can be accessed through the links at the top of the page, or HERE.
One point often overlooked, which I discuss there, is the extent to which the anomaly of the West Lothian question is made worse by problems of mis-representation, which are fuelled by using the First-past-the-post electoral system. The result is that Labour is disproportionately strong (compared to its share of the vote) in Scotland and Wales, as are both Conservatives and (somewhat less so) Labour in England. The Lib Dems in England, the SNP and Conservatives in Scotland, and Plaid Cymru and the Lib Dems in Wales are the main losers.
There are arguments on both sides of the question of proportional representation, but its absence creates these anomalies that mean Labour has far more Scottish and Welsh MPs than its share of the vote justifies, and the Conservatives more English MPs. A more equitable electoral system would reduce that disparity, and the degree to which the West Lothian question is played up or down for party advantage.
I’ll be saying something further about the possible solutions to the West Lothian question in the next few days.